Gun Island
- This blog is part of task given by Dr. Dilip Barad on unit Gun Island by Amitav Ghosh.
Thematic Study:
- Video-1 Etymological Mystery | Title of the Novel | Gun Island | Amitav Ghosh
Mindmap:
.png)
Infographic:
.png)
Slide:
Video:
Research Activity:
- Climate fiction (Cli-Fi) and literary studies:
Prompt 1: Create a table showing each source with its publication dates,author credentials,and whether its primary source, secondary analysis or opinion piece.
Prompt 2: Which of these sources are more frequently cited or referenced by other sources in this notebook ?
The Most Cited Work: Amitav Ghosh
Amitav Ghosh’s The Great Derangement: Climate Change and the Unthinkable (2016) is the most frequently referenced work in the notebook. It is the primary subject of entire academic papers and book reviews, and is cited as a seminal critique of the modern novel's failure to address the climate crisis in nearly every academic overview provided.
The "Theoretical Pillars" of Cli-Fi Study:
Beyond Ghosh, several other scholarly works are consistently cited across the notebook's academic papers to provide theoretical frameworks for analysis:
• Adam Trexler (Anthropocene Fictions: The Novel in a Time of Climate Change): Frequently cited for establishing a timeline of climate narratives and for his argument that the Anthropocene transforms literary forms.
• Ursula K. Heise (Sense of Place and Sense of Planet): Referenced for her concepts of "eco-cosmopolitanism" and the "environmental imaginary of the global," particularly in discussions regarding global versus local environmentalism.
• Rob Nixon (Slow Violence and the Environmentalism of the Poor): Cited extensively for his theory of "slow violence" invisible, long-term environmental degradation and its impact on marginalized communities.
• Lawrence Buell (The Environmental Imagination): Cited as a foundational figure in ecocriticism who defined "environmental texts" and their relationship to nature writing.
• Timothy Morton (Hyperobjects): Frequently referenced for his definition of "hyperobjects" phenomena like global warming that are too vast in time and space for humans to fully grasp.
Authors Who Are Also Sources:
Several contributors to the notebook are also cited by other sources within the same set of documents:
• Adeline Johns-Putra: The author of the "Advanced Review" on climate change in literature is cited as a major authority in the "Comprehensive Analysis", the "Australian Journal of Environmental Education" (AJEE), the University of Copenhagen's glossary, and the Saunders paper.
• Dan Bloom: Credited in multiple sources as the journalist who coined the term "cli-fi" in 2007/2008.
• Mykaela Saunders: The author of "Reading Climate Fiction through First Nations Cultural Genre Theory" is cited and discussed as a key contributor to Indigenous futurisms in the "Comprehensive Analysis" and the AJEE editorial.
Source "Citation Hubs":
Two sources in this notebook act as citational hubs because they provide comprehensive bibliographies that reference nearly all other provided sources:
1. "Climate Fiction and the Evolution of Environmental Literary Studies: A Comprehensive Analysis": This source references almost every other source's publication or author in its extensive endnotes.
2. "Climate Fiction of the Anthropocene" (AJEE Editorial): This editorial introduces and cites a large number of the other authors and specific papers present in this notebook.
The notebook functions like a citational ecosystem: while many sources branch out into specific niches like Caribbean or Indigenous fiction, they all remain rooted in the common soil of a few "canonical" texts by thinkers like Ghosh, Trexler, and Heise.
Prompt 3: Summarize the primary perspective of the top five most substantial sources
1. The Comprehensive Evolution Synthesis
This source argues that cli-fi has evolved from a niche subgenre into a robust category of academic study that bridges the gap between abstract scientific data and human experience. Its primary perspective is that these narratives make "hyperobjects" entities like global warming that are too vast to conceptualize tangible and emotionally resonant for a general audience. The analysis traces a trajectory from "green pessimism" and apocalyptic spectacles toward "hopeful cli-fi" and solarpunk, which utilize polyphonic narration to imagine systemic reform and institutional agency rather than just individual survival.
2. The Canon-Shaping Advanced Review (Johns-Putra)
Adeline Johns-Putra provides a foundational overview that categorizes the field into primary literary engagements (fiction, drama, and poetry) and secondary critical responses (ecocriticism and climate change criticism). Her perspective is that climate change is a topic found across many genres including thrillers, romance, and psychological studies rather than being a single, rigid genre. She distinguishes between normative ecocriticism, which seeks to teach readers how to adapt to the crisis, and objective ecocriticism, which analyzes the representational challenges of depicting the "unthinkable" scale of climate change.
3. First Nations Cultural Genre Theory (Saunders)
Mykaela Saunders offers a critical counter-perspective to Western literary theory, arguing that for Indigenous people, all stories begin and end with Country. She rejects the Western definition of cli-fi as a "new" literary phenomenon set in the future, noting that First Nations people have experienced "ecocide" and apocalypse since 1788 due to colonization. Her perspective emphasizes "Blackfella Futurism," where traditional Countries are viewed as future Countries, and storytelling serves as a sovereignty-focused technology to revitalize the land through human stewardship and ceremonial activation.
4. Pedagogical and Transformative Force (AJEE Editorial)
This source focuses on the role of storytelling as an integral component of environmental education. The authors argue that cli-fi is a tool for "futures feeling" as much as futures thinking, allowing learners to emotionally integrate the climate crisis into their lives. Their perspective frames cli-fi as "creative practice-as-research," suggesting that the act of creating stories allows students to disrupt conventional thinking and realize decolonial, intersectional futures.
5. The Theoretical Rebuttal to Ghosh (Heise)
Ursula K. Heise provides a significant scholarly critique of Amitav Ghosh’s The Great Derangement, challenging his claim that the modern novel is structurally incapable of addressing climate change. While acknowledging Ghosh’s "History" essay as brilliant for shifting focus to imperialism and Asian centrality, she argues that he wrongly dismisses science fiction. Her perspective is that science fiction's ability to embrace nonhuman agents and vast temporal scales makes it the default and most effective genre for navigating the Anthropocene, regardless of whether it is accepted by the "mainstream" literary establishment.
Prompt 4: Identify ‘Research Gap’ for further research in this area.
1. Disproportionate Focus and Authorial Erasure:
A primary gap identified is the unbalanced critical attention given to a very small subset of authors.
• Settler Scholarship Bias: Despite the existence of over 130 examples of First Nations speculative fiction, a "hugely disproportionate amount" of scholarship focuses on only three writers: Alexis Wright, Ambelin Kwaymullina, and Claire G. Coleman. The vast majority of First Nations writers receive little to no critical engagement, and even when they are studied, they are rarely analyzed through an authentic cultural lens.
• Exclusion from Comparative Studies: Even recent studies investigating the experiences of climate fiction authors have failed to include Indigenous perspectives, effectively perpetuating their erasure from the discourse.
2. The Gap Between Science and the Arts:
There remains a "lack of a substantial connection" between literary and scientific approaches to the environment.
• Aesthetic vs. Empirical: Many environmental studies treat nature solely as an aesthetic object rather than a scientific one, fearing that scientific inquiry might undermine beauty. This has resulted in a lack of a "genuine conceptual bridge" between scientific explanation and artistic assessment.
• Skepticism of Scientific Methodology: A portion of the environmental movement views science with skepticism, blaming it for the industrialization that caused the crisis, which hinders interdisciplinary dialogue.
3. Limited Empirical Evidence on Behavioral Change:
While there is growing interest in the social influence of cli-fi, empirical data on its long-term efficacy is lacking.
• Short-term Impact: Controlled experiments show that while reading cli-fi can have positive effects on attitudes, these effects often diminish to statistical insignificance after just one month.
• Attitude vs. Action: While these narratives shift policy support and attitudes, they have shown "less evidence of directly influencing immediate financial behavior," such as charitable donations.
• Potential Backfire: Some research suggests that dystopian climate narratives may lead to "reactionary responses" or "intensely negative emotions" that could be counterproductive to environmental engagement.
4. Structural and Methodological Gaps:
Scholars have identified a need for new frameworks to handle the scale of the Anthropocene.
• The "National vs. Transnational" Challenge: A significant challenge remains in finding a theoretical framework that can effectively bridge the gap between the "transnational" nature of postcolonial history and the "national" (often American/UK-centric) frameworks of early ecocriticism.
• Non-Anthropocentric Limitations: There is a persistent question of how to pivot away from human-centric perspectives when fiction is inherently written in human language and focalized through human voices.
• Base and Superstructure Analysis: Using a Marxist lens, further research is needed to explore how market-driven ideologies specifically manipulate literary production to prioritize individualism over the collective, systemic nature of climate change.
5. Theoretical Reconciliations in "Postcolonial Green":
Further research is required to navigate the materialist nuances of environmental history.
• Materialist Viewpoints: Scholars call for a more comprehensive navigation between the formal and stylistic elements of literature and their specific historical environmental contexts, particularly in the Global South.
• Spatial Subconscious: There is room to further develop the concept of the "spatial subconscious" how art and literature can help a recipient develop an awareness of local environments as integral to the survival of the broader human race.
Inforaphics:
Mindmap:
Briefing on Climate Fiction: Narrative, Theory, and Cultural Impact
Executive Summary:
Climate Fiction, or "Cli-Fi," has emerged as a significant literary and cultural phenomenon dedicated to exploring the multifaceted crisis of climate change. This briefing synthesizes an analysis of the genre's definition, its central theoretical critiques, its narrative conventions, and its expanding role in academia and education. A seminal work in this field is Amitav Ghosh's The Great Derangement (2016), which argues that the modern realist novel is structurally ill-equipped to address the planetary scale and "uncanny" nature of climate change, leading to an imaginative and cultural failure.
Cli-Fi serves to make the abstract data of climate science tangible and emotionally resonant, bridging the gap between scientific discourse and human experience. While the genre is often characterized by dystopian and post-apocalyptic settings that explore themes of social collapse, resource scarcity, and survival, there is a growing movement of more hopeful narratives, such as Solarpunk, that envision sustainable futures.
The genre is not confined to the novel, extending to theater, poetry, film, and other media. Furthermore, Cli-Fi is enriched by global and decolonial perspectives, particularly from Caribbean speculative fiction, which challenges Western-centric tropes and links ecological justice with gender and racial equity. Within academia, Cli-Fi is a cornerstone of the environmental humanities and a vital pedagogical tool that fosters critical engagement with environmental ethics, promotes "futures thinking," and empowers individuals to imagine and enact change.
1. Defining Climate Fiction (Cli-Fi):
Climate Fiction is a literary and cultural category that addresses human-induced climate change and its ramifications. While its sensibilities can be traced to earlier environmental literature, its formal identity has solidified in the 21st century.
• Origin of the Term: The term "cli-fi" was coined in 2007 by journalist Dan Bloom to reframe discussions on global warming and provide a platform for narrative explorations beyond scientific data.
• Genre Boundaries and Taxonomy: The precise definition of cli-fi remains a subject of academic debate. It is often considered a subgenre of science fiction (sci-fi) or, more broadly, eco-fiction.
◦ Cli-Fi vs. Science Fiction: While sci-fi often explores futuristic technology and space, cli-fi is predominantly Earth-based, focusing on nature's power and the vulnerability of life in the face of ecological disruption.
◦ Eco-Fiction: A broader category dealing with humanity's impact on nature. Cli-fi is a specific subset of eco-fiction that centers on anthropogenic global warming as a primary plot driver.
◦ Related Categories: The genre can incorporate elements of "green fiction" (realist mode), the "ecological uncanny" (familiar landscapes becoming alien), and "eco-horror" (nature fighting back against human overreach).
• Scope Across Media: Although the novel is its dominant form, cli-fi encompasses a wide range of cultural texts, including print, performance, theater, film, games, visual art, and comics.
2. The Seminal Critique of Amitav Ghosh:
Indian author Amitav Ghosh's 2016 non-fiction work, The Great Derangement: Climate Change and the Unthinkable, provides one of the most significant theoretical interventions in the study of climate fiction. Ghosh argues that contemporary literary forms are structurally inadequate for grappling with the climate crisis.
• The Core Argument: Ghosh contends that the modern realist novel, which developed alongside a belief in the world's stability (uniformitarianism) and the carbon economy, is ill-equipped to handle the "uncanny" scale of climate change. Its focus on individual "moral adventures" within a narrow time frame renders the planetary crisis "unthinkable" or invisible.
• The Three "Derangements": Ghosh identifies a systemic failure across three cultural domains:
1. Stories: The novel's preoccupation with character-driven, bourgeois regularities prevents it from adequately depicting the extraordinary and "freak" weather events that define climatic rupture.
2. History: The standard narrative of the Anthropocene is often Western-centric, focusing on European industrialization. Ghosh argues for an Asian perspective where climate change is intertwined with empire, noting that colonial powers often suppressed industrial development in the Global South.
3. Politics: Modern politics and literature share a preoccupation with individualism and symbolic gestures, failing to foster the collective, systemic change necessary to address the crisis.
• Critique of Genre Relegation: Ghosh questions why serious fiction is reluctant to engage with climate change and why, when it does, the work is often relegated to subgenres like science fiction or fantasy.
He argues this is an ethical violation, as climate change is not an "imagined 'other' world" but a reality of our own time and place.
3. Thematic Landscape and Narrative Conventions
Cli-fi narratives employ a range of settings and thematic approaches to explore the consequences of ecological crisis.
• Dystopian and Post-Apocalyptic Futures: This is the most prevalent mode in cli-fi. These narratives often depict grim futuristic scenarios marked by:
◦ Environmental Collapse: Extreme weather, massive sea-level rise, droughts, and heatwaves.
◦ Social and Economic Instability: Themes include climate refugeeism, resource wars (especially over water), technological over-reliance, and deep social divisions, as seen in the "split world" of corporate compounds versus polluted "pleeblands" in Margaret Atwood's work.
• Present-Day Realism: A smaller number of novels are set in the present, focusing on the immediate ethical, political, and psychological dilemmas of climate change. These stories often feature scientists, environmentalists, and ordinary people grappling with ecological disasters and moral choices.
• The Satirical Mode: Some works approach climate change with satire and dark comedy, critiquing human folly, selfishness, and institutional bureaucracy. Ian McEwan's Solar is a prominent example, centering on a flawed physicist who represents humanity's worst impulses.
• Hopeful and Utopian Narratives: In response to the prevalence of dystopianism, a hopeful strain of cli-fi has emerged.
◦ Solarpunk: This aesthetic and subgenre replaces dark dystopia with visions of green technology, social harmony, and sustainable coexistence.
◦ Institutional and Policy Focus: Works like Kim Stanley Robinson's The Ministry for the Future explore systemic reform and policy responses, offering a "determined optimism" rather than fatalism.
4. The Developing Canon of Climate Fiction
As ecocriticism and literary studies engage more deeply with climate change, a canon of key cli-fi texts is emerging across various media.
- Landmark Novels:
Author | Landmark Novel(s) | Publication Year(s) | Primary Environmental Catalyst / Theme |
|---|---|---|---|
Margaret Atwood | MaddAddam trilogy | 2003, 2009, 2013 | Plague, genetic engineering, catastrophic climate change |
Paolo Bacigalupi | The Windup Girl, The Water Knife | 2009, 2015 | Bio-engineered pandemics, heat, resource wars (water) |
Kim Stanley Robinson | Science in the Capital trilogy, New York 2140, The Ministry for the Future | 2004-2007, 2017, 2020 | Abrupt climate change, massive sea-level rise, global heatwaves, policy response |
Barbara Kingsolver | Flight Behavior | 2012 | Biological displacement and its impact on a rural community |
Cormac McCarthy | The Road | 2006 | Unspecified environmental catastrophe, survival, loss of biosphere |
Ian McEwan | Solar | 2010 | Satirical exploration of scientific hubris and artificial photosynthesis |
Jeanette Winterson | The Stone Gods | 2007 | Resource depletion, planetary relocation, cyclical destruction |
Jeff VanderMeer | Annihilation (Southern Reach trilogy) | 2014 | Ecological uncanny, "New Weird," mysterious environmental transformation |
Alexis Wright | The Swan Book | 2013 | First Nations perspective on climate refugeeism and colonial violence |
Tim Winton | Juice | N/A | Dystopian vision of societal collapse driven by runaway industrial interests |
- Climate Change in Theater and Poetry:
• Theater: Climate change theater has seen a significant increase in productions since 2009, with notable plays like Steve Waters's The Contingency Plan (2009), Mike Bartlett's Earthquakes in London (2010), and Richard Bean's The Heretic (2011). These works often explore the ethical burdens on scientists and the psychological impact of apocalyptic warnings.
• Ecopoetry: Rooted in nature poetry, ecopoetry engages with contemporary environmental degradation. Climate change poetry is a growing subset characterized by elegies for nonhuman species, regret for the future, and protest against human inaction.
5. Global and Decolonial Perspectives
A crucial evolution within cli-fi is the amplification of non-Western and decolonial voices, which challenge dominant narratives and connect climate change to histories of colonialism, empire, and racial injustice.
• Challenging Western-Centrism: Following Ghosh's critique, scholars highlight how the climate crisis is inseparable from imperialism and the unequal distribution of emissions and impacts between the Global North and South, a phenomenon Rob Nixon terms "slow violence."
• Caribbean Speculative Fiction: This is a particularly rich site for reimagining climate futures.
◦ Resisting the "Disappearing Islands" Trope: Authors actively resist the deterministic trope that portrays small islands as mere proof of catastrophe. Instead, they envision futures of transformation, persistence, and survival.
◦ Queer and Trans Chronotropics: Writers like Nalo Hopkinson ("Repatriation") and Ada Maricia Patterson ("Broken from the Colony") utilize queer and trans perspectives to imagine futures where ecological balance and gender justice are intertwined. They employ "chronotropics" a framework collapsing past, present, and future to subvert colonial temporalities and propose new forms of relationality and repair.
◦ Focus on Local Agency: These narratives center local technologies, community-based action, and a refusal of colonial infrastructures, imagining futures built "upon its ruins."
Perspective | Narrative Strategy | Core Theme |
|---|---|---|
First Nations | "Songlines" and ceremonial activation | Sovereignty, land stewardship, and anti-colonialism |
Caribbean | "Chronotropics" and queering the future | Resistance to disappearance and gender justice |
West African | Rooted science fiction and local resonance | Community action and anti-imperialism |
Asian | Historical carbon economy and urban sprawl | Displacement, migration, and the "carbon cloud" |
Latin American | Speculative realism and systemic critique | Corporate exploitation and ecological resilience |
6. The Role of Cli-Fi in Academia and Education
Cli-Fi is not only a literary genre but also a powerful tool for academic inquiry and pedagogy, primarily within the environmental humanities.
• A Field of Study: Cli-Fi is a central topic in ecocriticism and climate change criticism. Scholars analyze how narratives represent the complexities of the climate crisis, shape public perception, and reflect societal attitudes toward risk.
• Pedagogical Utility: In educational settings, cli-fi serves several key functions:
◦ Making the Abstract Concrete: It translates the vast, abstract scale of "hyperobjects" like climate change into tangible, emotionally resonant stories.
◦ Fostering Empathy and Ethics: By dramatizing the consequences of ecological mismanagement, it serves as a vehicle for reflection on environmental ethics and social justice.
◦ Encouraging Futures Thinking: It is used to empower students to engage in not just "futures thinking" but also "futures feeling," imagining both dystopian and utopian possibilities.
◦ Promoting Agency: The creation and critique of cli-fi can help students understand complexity, untangle emotions like despair, and exert their agency to demand a better future.
• A Transformative Force: Environmental educators view cli-fi as more than a resource; it is "a way of being" that integrates climate change into lived experience ("climating") and uses storytelling to dream of and realize transformative change.
7. Theoretical and Philosophical Dimensions
The rise of cli-fi has been accompanied by the development of new theoretical frameworks for understanding the current era and the existential challenges it poses.
• The Anthropocene: This term for the current geological epoch, defined by human influence on the planet, is a central concept. However, it is also contested, with critics proposing alternatives to highlight specific drivers of the crisis:
◦ Capitalocene (Jason Moore): Emphasizes the role of capitalism.
◦ Chthulucene (Donna Haraway): Focuses on multispecies entanglements.
◦ Critiques of "Anthropos": Scholars like Kathryn Yusoff argue the term obscures the violent histories of colonialism and extraction, demanding recognition of "a billion black Anthropocenes or none."
• Climate Change Criticism: This field of literary theory treats climate change as a profound philosophical and existentialist problem. It argues that the climate crisis acts as a deconstructive force, revealing the inconsistencies in core cultural concepts like "nature," history, and humanism.
• Key Concepts:
◦ Hyperobjects (Timothy Morton): Entities like global warming that are so vast in temporal and spatial scale they defy traditional human conceptualization.
◦ Slow Violence (Rob Nixon): The delayed, attritional, and often invisible violence of environmental catastrophe that disproportionately affects the poor and marginalized.
◦ Risk Society (Ulrich Beck): The idea that modern society is organized around anticipating and managing the hazards and insecurities of the future, a concept frequently applied to cli-fi narratives.
Prompt 5: Draft literature review ending with hypotheses and research questions pertaining to this research gap.
- Literature Review:
The emergence of climate fiction (cli-fi) as a distinct cultural phenomenon represents a significant pivot in literary history, moving beyond abstract scientific data to provide an emotional prism for understanding global warming. First coined by Dan Bloom in 2007, the term has evolved from a niche subgenre of speculative fiction into a robust academic category that interrogates the relationship between human culture and the physical environment.
- Theoretical Foundations:
A central tension in the field is defined by Amitav Ghosh’s seminal work, The Great Derangement, which argues that the modern realist novel is structurally ill-equipped to handle the scale and "uncanny" nature of climate change. Ghosh contends that the novel's traditional focus on individual "moral adventures" and "uniformitarian" predictability makes planetary-scale crises "unthinkable" within mainstream literary forms. However, scholars like Ursula K. Heise and Vandana Singh offer a rebuttal, asserting that science fiction and speculative genres have successfully addressed these challenges for decades by utilizing nonhuman agents, vast temporal scales, and "what-if" experiments to interrogate the present.
- Expanding the Canon:
Recent scholarship emphasizes that climate narratives are not a monolithic Western movement. Postcolonial ecocriticism, drawing on Rob Nixon’s concept of "slow violence," analyzes how environmental degradation in the Global South is inextricably linked to imperial plunder and extractive capitalism. Similarly, First Nations cultural genre theory challenges the Western view of cli-fi as a "new" genre, noting that for Indigenous peoples, climate catastrophe is a historical reality initiated by colonization. Indigenous writers utilize "Blackfella Futurism" to envision sovereignty and land stewardship as essential technologies for survival. In the Caribbean, writers use "chronotropics" to subvert colonial temporalities, imagining islands not as "disappearing" tokens of catastrophe but as transitioning spaces of resistance.
Identifying the Critical Research Gaps:
Despite the field's growth, several "blind spots" persist. There is a disproportionate focus on a small subset of canonical authors; for instance, while over 130 First Nations speculative texts exist, critical attention is largely confined to three writers, effectively erasing a vast archive of diverse voices. Furthermore, a conceptual bridge between science and the arts remains missing, as literary studies often treat nature solely as an aesthetic object rather than engaging with hard scientific methodology. Additionally, while cli-fi is increasingly used in environmental education to foster "futures feeling," empirical evidence regarding its long-term impact on financial behavior or sustained environmental action remains thin and sometimes contradictory.
Hypotheses:
• H1: Critical engagement with non-canonical Indigenous and Global South authors will reveal narrative strategies that emphasize systemic institutional reform over the individualistic "commonplace hero" trope prevalent in Western cli-fi.
• H2: Interdisciplinary pedagogies that integrate hard scientific modeling with speculative narrative creation will result in higher "ecological consciousness" and long-term behavioral retention compared to purely aesthetic literary analysis.
• H3: Dystopian climate narratives that lack decolonial or restorative frameworks are more likely to trigger "reactionary responses" or avoidant coping mechanisms in readers, whereas "hopeful cli-fi" (e.g., solarpunk) increases policy support.
Research Questions:
1. How does the "authorial erasure" of the majority of First Nations speculative writers impact the theoretical development of "postcolonial green" frameworks in environmental humanities?
2. Can the "spatial subconscious" developed through local, place-based climate stories effectively scale up to create a global "eco-cosmopolitan" identity without erasing local historical injustices?
3. What specific narrative structures (e.g., polyphonic narration, non-linear timelines) are most effective at making "hyperobjects" like ocean acidification tangible to readers without triggering defensive denial?
4. To what extent does the "do-gooder derogation" effect limit the effectiveness of cli-fi as a tool for driving immediate financial contributions to climate justice movements?
Thank You
Comments
Post a Comment